The detail behind the mitigation promises.
Environmental protection depends on more than a predicted number. The regulators asked how the process, its emissions and water controls actually work.
DAERA’s September 2025 response identified missing information relevant to assessing impacts on protected habitats and the water environment.
Ammonia, nitrogen and designated habitats
DAERA Natural Environment Division requested a fuller description of the production process, including handling, mixing, conditioning, pelletising and other stages that could produce emissions. It also requested revised ammonia, nitrogen-deposition and nitrogen oxides assessment details and abatement manufacturer specifications.
Crucially, the applicant’s original dispersion report predicts relatively low impacts under its modelled inputs. The regulator did not conclude in the September response that emissions would necessarily exceed relevant standards. The question is whether all emission sources and treatment efficiencies are properly represented.
↗ DAERA Natural Environment Division · ↗ Applicant nitrogen assessmentWater containment is not the same as flood drainage
DAERA Water Management Unit requested detailed information on impermeable handling areas, the collection tank, wash-water and liquid handling, the origin and authorisation of incoming digestate and the destination of finished material or associated liquid by-products.
Separately, DfI Rivers assessed the storm-water drainage proposals and said it had no sustainable drainage/flood-risk objection if the submitted measures were implemented.
DfI Rivers gave a favourable response to the proposed attenuation arrangement, subject to implementation.
↗ Read DfI RiversDAERA WMU requested evidence on digestate-related runoff, engineered containment and handling of liquids.
↗ Read DAERA WMUThese are different questions. A favourable flood-risk consultation does not settle every possible operational pollution pathway.
Numerical discrepancies in the air report
Two inconsistencies in the applicant's published air-quality report deserve clarification:
3,700 versus 3,600
Table 8 gives a total odour emission rate of 3,700 ou/s, while the accompanying sentence refers to 3,600 ou/s being modelled.
↗ AQIA · p. 140.120 versus 0.012
Table 17 lists 0.120 kg N/ha/year for receptor E1, while the following commentary refers to 0.012.
↗ AQIA · p. 25These may be reporting errors rather than model errors. The correct approach is to ask which figures were used and whether the underlying calculations change — not to claim that they demonstrate pollution or a regulatory exceedance.
Ecology: what the applicant itself acknowledges
The applicant's ecological appraisal anticipates roadside hedgerow removal for visibility, with replacement planting, and sets out protective measures for retained habitat. The ecology consultant predicts generally negligible ecological effects if the proposed safeguards are implemented.
The ecological assessment is therefore evidence of **actual proposed landscape intervention**, rather than evidence that the consultant itself predicts catastrophic biodiversity harm.
↗ Ecological appraisal · p. 45Environmental Statement: what the Council actually decided
On 5 September 2025 the Council determined that the proposal did not require an Environmental Statement under the EIA screening process. That is the recorded screening decision; it is not planning permission, and does not remove the need to assess environmental effects through the normal planning process.
↗ EIA screening letterThe question is compatibility, not simply zoning.
Read the statutory tests and examine the actual application documents for yourself.
Read the policy tests ↗ Browse documents ↗